"[Grinberg's] book on one of the most important films of the glasnost' era will be of interest and importance to movie buffs as well as students and teachers of Russian film and literature."

Slavic and East European Journal

"Marat Grinberg’s film companion to The Commissar... aims to demonstrate that Aleksandr Askoldov’s only film is not only an indispensable historical artifact for understanding late Soviet cinematic politics, but also one of the greatest films of European post-war cinema, placing Askoldov in the company of acknowledged masters such as Francois Truffaut, Luchino Visconti and Jean-Luc Godard... Grinberg... excels in ferreting out literary antecedents to the film [and] is most effective in explaining the myriad ways in which Askoldov embeds Jewish motifs, images, language and folk culture into the film... It is hard to imagine a more complete analysis of this aspect of The Commissar."

Studies in Russian and Soviet Cinema:

"Marat Grinberg argues that Aleksandr Askoldov’s four primary intertextual references in The Commissar came from literature. They were the authors Vasilii Grossman (on whose short story, In the Town of Berdichev, Askoldov based his screenplay), Mikhail Bulgakov (on whom Askoldov wrote his unfinished dissertation at Moscow State University’s philology department), Isaak Babel΄ (whose Red Cavalry was one of the film’s explicit sources), and Pavel Kogan (whose poem about the Bolshevik revolution, written in 1939–1941, was published in 1965). Perhaps even more strikingly and in contrast to previous writings on Askoldov’s film, Grinberg reframes The Commissar as a Jewish film."

Maria Belodubrovskaya | Slavic Review