The Restless Clock
A History of the Centuries-Long Argument over What Makes Living Things Tick
The Restless Clock
A History of the Centuries-Long Argument over What Makes Living Things Tick
The Restless Clock examines the history of this principle, banning agency, in the life sciences. It also tells the story of dissenters embracing the opposite idea: that agency is essential to nature. The story begins with the automata of early modern Europe, as models for the new science of living things, and traces questions of science and agency through Descartes, Leibniz, Lamarck, and Darwin, among many others. Mechanist science, Jessica Riskin shows, had an associated theology: the argument from design, which found evidence for a designer in the mechanisms of nature. Rejecting such appeals to a supernatural God, the dissenters sought to naturalize agency rather than outsourcing it to a “divine engineer.” Their model cast living things not as passive but as active, self-making machines.
The conflict between passive- and active-mechanist approaches maintains a subterranean life in current science, shaping debates in fields such as evolutionary biology, cognitive science, and artificial intelligence. This history promises not only to inform such debates, but also our sense of the possibilities for what it means to engage in science—and even what it means to be alive.
"The Restless Clock is a sweeping survey of the search for answers to the mystery of life. Riskin writes with clarity and wit, and the breadth of her scholarship is breathtaking."
Times Higher Education
"The most influential book of the past twenty years. . . . Interest in the similarities and the differences between human beings and machines goes back many centuries--and Jessica Riskin's The Restless Clock is a rich and resonant telling of that long history. . . . Riskin's sweeping survey isn’t didactic or moralizing, but it contains two vitally important lessons for us: Never bet against human ingenuity in making machines do what people once considered impossible. And never bet against human ingenuity in redefining the uniquely human such that machine-intelligence can never match our own."
Steven Shapin | Chronicle of Higher Education
"At the heart of this scientific and cultural history is the concept of agency—the capacity to act—in nature. Riskin reveals how two distinct interpretations emerged from the mechanical Universe of the Enlightenment: Isaac Newton’s passive version, reliant on a divine tinkerer; and Gottfried Leibniz’s, which saw life as purposeful and 'self-transforming.' Riskin’s investigation of this duality, by way of Renaissance automatons, the gestation of evolutionary theory and quantum mechanics, is engrossing and illuminating."
"Wide-ranging, witty, and astonishingly learned."
London Review of Books
"Riskin uses history as a way of thinking about the world, not just as a way of getting facts about the past right. She shows us the many ways in which scholars have sought to understand those parts of the world that are material, movable and predictable, and those that are characterized by agency, passions, chance, suffering and consciousness, as well as the tricky areas where they overlap. She mobilizes powerful examples from the history of the life sciences of where and how attempts at explaining these areas have succeeded and failed. Her journey takes us everywhere in the best possible way as she probes the limits of our efforts to explain—through science and through history—how the world works inside and outside the realm of our agency, purposes and reasoning."
Times Literary Supplement
“[Restless Clock] illustrates not only how these machines inspired modern theories of life, but also how the language we use to describe them has important consequences.…it helps us understand the backstory, and the world-altering consequences of language; it joins an important literature in calling for far greater vigilance in the metaphors we use to understand not only ourselves, but also our creations.”
Los Angeles Review of Books
“The Restless Clock is gorgeous and erudite, full of flute-playing androids and defecating ducks, animal spirits and invisible forces. It explores the hardest problems: where does life come from, and how is it that thoughts seem to dance out of grey matter? This is a book that brings history and language to bear on contemporary science—an important thing in itself in an age where science sometimes looks set to obliterate the humanities.”
“In this rich, sweeping history, Riskin explores the dialectic between mechanistic models of nature from the mid-17th century forward. The author's main interest is in the notion of "agency" or purposefulness, which has been banned from scientific discourse by the dominant brute-mechanist paradigm; struggle between models, she argues, has been going on since modern science's inception and it influences debates today in the fields of evolutionary biology, cognitive science, and artificial intelligence. The work of luminaries such as René Descartes, Gottfried Wilhelm Leibniz, Immanuel Kant, Jean-Baptiste Lamarck, and Charles Darwin is discussed, as well as that of contemporaries including Daniel Dennett, Richard Dawkins, and Stephen Jay Gould. But there are also the lesser knowns: the clockmakers, court mechanics, artisans, and their fantastic assortment of gadgets, automata, and androids that stood as models for the nascent life sciences. Riskin's accounts of these automata will come as a revelation to many readers, as she traces their history from late medieval, early Renaissance clock- and organ-driven devils and muttering Christs in churches to the robots of the post-World War II era. Fascinating on many levels, this book is accessible enough for a science-minded lay audience yet useful for students and scholars.”
"Riskin’s book begins with Descartes and automata and traces the development of ideas about what animates living things up to the present. Science long ago moved away from theories about a divine clockmaker, but Riskin says some of the ideas from that period persist in surprising form. In particular, she says, atheist philosophers and scientists who regard consciousness in purely mechanistic terms, are inadvertently borrowing a schematic that, in a different time, struck people as evidence of God."
"Riskin has written a lengthy, detailed, impressive monograph based on her concern over a vital paradox of science. The author begins by discussing the argument that some scientific ideas commenced with a model of nature as a clock, which God designed and produced. This argument appeared to be supported by clever automata, which medieval mechanics had developed in Christian churches. Soon there were objections to that model, and skeptics seemed to triumph with Darwin’s theory of evolution by natural selection in The Origin of Species (1859). However, there are philosophers of science who still argue that Darwin’s theory is an incomplete understanding of nature, and Riskin takes this claim very seriously. Highly recommended."
“[M]uch of the intellectual energy of the modern era has been devoted to figuring out whether the non-human world is alive or dead, active or passive, full of agency or wholly without it. Jessica Riskin’s extraordinary book The Restless Clock tells that vital and almost wholly neglected story…. The body of powerful, influential, but now utterly neglected ideas explored in The Restless Clock might illuminate for many scientists and many philosophers a few of their pervasive blind spots. ‘By recognizing the historical roots of the almost unanimous conviction (in principle if not in practice) that science must not attribute any kind of agency to natural phenomena, and recuperating the historical presence of a competing tradition, we can measure the limits of current scientific discussion, and possibly, think beyond them.’”
Education & Culture: A Critical Review
"Riskin's book provides an excellent strictly chronological examination of the development of two strands of mechanistic thinking since the seventeenth century. In the course of doing so she provides accessible and clearly written introductions to the central ideas of philosophers and scientists who have engaged in mechanistic thinking. Moreover, Riskin's book is a treasure trove of information about the history of machines and automata. . . . A highly valuable, clearly written, and extremely informative contribution to the literature on mechanistic science and the history of
machines and machine metaphors in the life sciences."
History and Philosophy of the Life Sciences
"Recuperating the tradition of active mechanism—the vision of an animated yet material universe—Riskin demonstrates what a powerful challenge it poses to contemporary modes of thought that claim the authority of science. Ultimately, The Restless Clock offers nothing less than an alternative way of seeing the natural world, and being in it."
"The Restless Clock unravels the history of thinking about agency in the history of modern science so as to determine how mechanism and passivity became the dominant paradigm. In this expansive work—which draws on primary sources, correspondences between intellectual radicals, and archival materials from across the Western world—Riskin expertly demonstrates not only how the principle of passivity came to dominate modern science in the first place but also how this principle has influenced contemporary science. In taking on the problem of agency as supposedly banished from modern science, she compels us to think about how agency is actually essential in and to nature. Riskin captivatingly tells the story of this “centuries-long argument” over agency with the patience, precision, and the profound depth of explanation that history demands. The Restless Clock provides a much-needed investigation of how scientific understandings of material reality have been undergirded by historical understandings and calls for more deliberate historical analysis not only in scientific work, but also in critical analyses of scientific discourse and ideology. Such a work deepens our comprehension and awareness of the taken-for-granted ideologies that underpin modern science and, subsequently, the contemporary challenges posed to it by movements such as new materialisms. The Restless Clock will become a frequent reference for anyone interested in the matter of matter."
"This timeless fascination with the question of what it means to be living has been explored most recently be Riskin, a history professor at Stanford University. In her latest book, The Restless Clock, she moves past the previous theologically and philosophically grounded discussions and looks at these questions of autonomy through the lens of a historian....By putting forth these questions in the words of past intellectuals, Riskin engages the reader in evaluating these existential questions with respect to big-picture “processes” like evolution, artificial intelligence and epistemology."
"Astonishing. The Restless Clock...has seriously altered my understanding of the last five hundred years of intellectual and cultural history, and has significantly intensified my belief that the only truly theological account of modernity is one deeply immersed in the technological history of this past half-millennium."
The New Atlantis
"An extraordinary achievement."
"Riskin’s fascinating and lively book reframes the conventional narrative of the scientific revolution by tracing the passive and active strains in mechanistic philosophy. She convincingly demonstrates how the view of nature as inert passive matter was theologically based and that it contrasted with the view of nature as mechanical and active. The book made me rethink several assumptions I had about the history of what we now call biology and brought further nuance to contemporary debates about machine and organic intelligence."
Siri Hustvedt | The Guardian
"In this impressive cultural and intellectual narrative of the sciences of life and the techniques of mechanics, Riskin shows decisively how a richer and broader history of such sciences offers indispensable lessons for controversies surrounding agency and purpose in our understanding of the world. The Restless Clock explores fascinating projects launched by medieval churchmen and Renaissance artisans, enlightened philosophers and modern experimenters. It documents the construction of automata and experimentation in biology, the ambitions of Darwinism and of germ theory, the visions of cybernetics and of neurosciences. These stories reveal the power and importance of a tradition of living machines within the development of western sciences that has been strangely underestimated or dismissed. Its legacies today need just this kind of astute re-evaluation.
This book will become a central reference for many vital debates about the long history of life sciences and the possible futures of intelligent machines."
Simon Schaffer, coauthor of Leviathan and the Air-Pump
"The Restless Clock examines more than four centuries of debate over the extent to which living beings can be understood as governed by 'mechanism,' and in the process it reorients our understanding of some of the most important themes and individuals in the Western canon during this period, including the thought of Descartes, Leibniz, Kant, Lamarck, and Darwin, plus contemporaries such as Dennett, Dawkins, and Gould, among others. Riskin has written a work of tremendous intellectual scope and accomplishment."
Ken Alder, author of The Lie Detectors
"In this original and masterful book, Riskin recounts how scientists, philosophers, artists, and mechanics have wrestled with the nature of vital entities on the page and canvas, in the workshop and in stone. Here among others are Vaucanson and Kant, Descartes, Leibniz, and Darwin, defecating ducks, talking heads, and robots—giving us both the unfamiliar and the familiar in a new light, presented with deft analysis in luminous prose."
Daniel J. Kevles, author of The Baltimore Case
“A wonderful contribution--and much needed corrective--to the history of European ideas about life and matter.”
Evelyn Fox Keller, author of The Mirage of a Space between Nature and Nurture
"In The Restless Clock, Jessica Riskin brings a fresh view to the historical discourse around the use of mechanical metaphors in biological thought. Using agency as her theoretical starting point, Riskin traces a line through the last six centuries of biological thought with thorough evidence and analysis."
"Wonderfully learned and entertaining."
Oren Harman | Raritan
"Modern biology is essentially flawed. This is the stark message that underlies the whole of Jessica Riskin’s intricately detailed, meticulously researched, and astonishingly wide-ranging book. . . . Thought-provoking and utterly engrossing."
"Among the many virtues of Riskin’s book, perhaps the greatest is its tremendous scope, and its author’s remarkable ability to handle all the periods, figures, and issues in it with equal mastery."
Journal of Modern History
"The Restless Clock is a work of high scholarly order. Considering its chronological and thematic embrace, this study makes for a challenging scholarly undertaking. The result is both impressive and rewarding. This book is the combined product of Riskin’s penchant for meticulous research as well as her judicious choices and penetrating readings of sources. She uncovers a rich and compelling story that should interest all historians and philosophers of science as well as scientists."
"There is an inherent contradiction at the heart of modern science since its inception, and [The Restless Clock] tells this story beautifully. The exclusion of 'agency' from scientific explanations has paradoxically rendered the appeal to a 'divine engineer' necessary; Riskin argues in this compelling and wide-ranging account of the history of mechanism in biological thought. . . . nothing short of a historical 'tour de force' that sheds new light on the history of mechanism and on the rise of the modern scientific worldview. Thanks to its historical breadth and depth of analysis, Riskin's ambitious book will continue to invigorate scholarship in the field of history of (life) science for decades."
Berichte zur Wissenschaftsgeschichte:
"Fascinating and important."
Tita Chico | Los Angeles Review of Books
"[A] magisterial book...[a] careful and learned study of agency...Riskin’s book is one major intervention in a developing concern about agency."
Victorian Literature and Culture
Table of Contents
Introduction: Huxley’s Joke, or the Problem of Agency in Nature and Science
1 Machines in the Garden
2 Descartes among the Machines
3 The Passive Telescope or the Restless Clock
4 The First Androids
5 The Adventures of Mr. Machine
6 Dilemmas of a Self- Organizing Machine
7 Darwin between the Machines
8 The Mechanical Egg and the Intelligent Egg
9 Outside In
10 History Matters