Skip to main content

Economics--Mathematical Politics or Science of Diminishing Returns?

Economics today cannot predict the likely outcome of specific events any better than it could in the time of Adam Smith. This is Alexander Rosenberg’s controversial challenge to the scientific status of economics. Rosenberg explains that the defining characteristic of any science is predictive improvability—the capacity to create more precise forecasts by evaluating the success of earlier predictions—and he forcefully argues that because economics has not been able to increase its predictive power for over two centuries, it is not a science.

Table of Contents

Ch. 1: What Does the Philosophy of Science Have to Do with Economics?
The real relation between philosophy and science
The mutual constraints of goals, theories, and rules
The proximate goals of economics
Ch. 2: Two Dead Ends in the Philosophy of Economics
Does philosophy constrain economics?
Economics without epistemology
The role of prediction in biology, physics, and economics
Ch. 3: Is Economic Theory Predictively Successful?
Friedman on the predictive weakness of economic theory
Leontief on the same subject
Are generic predictions enough?
Generic predictions in Keynesian macroeconomics and rational expectations theory
Gibbard and Varian on economic models as caricatures
Ch. 4: Neoclassical Economics as a Research Program
The methodology of scientific research programs
Lakatosian consolations for economists
Research programs and the demarcation problem
Down the slippery slope to McCloskey
Ch. 5: Economics and Intentional Psychology
Expectations and preferences, beliefs and desires
The problem of improvability
Economics and linguistics: Nelson’s gambit
Are there expectations and preferences?
Ch. 6: Could Economics Be a Biological Science?
The problem of exogenous tastes
Becker’s new theory of consumer choice
Stable preferences as human needs
Can we "naturalize" information?
Generic predictions and the temptation of biology
Darwin, Friedman, and Alchain
Equilibrium and information in evolution and economics
Ch. 7: Why General Equilibrium Theory?
"Economics just is general equilibrium analysis"
Can we have partial equilibrium without general equilibrium?
What needs explanation? Can general equilibrium theory explain it?
General equilibrium and the social contract
Are generic predictions enough after all?
Ch. 8: Is Economic Theory Mathematics?
Extremal theories and intentionality
Economics as applied mathematics
Microeconomics and Euclidean geometry
But is it science?


London Schl Econ/Political Science: Lakatos Award in Philosophy of Science

Be the first to know

Get the latest updates on new releases, special offers, and media highlights when you subscribe to our email lists!

Sign up here for updates about the Press