Need, Science, and Politics in Modern France
Need, Science, and Politics in Modern France
The result was the concept of the "vital minimum"--the living wage, a measure of physical and social needs. In this book, Dana Simmons traces the history of this concept, revealing the intersections between technologies of measurement, such as calorimeters and social surveys, and technologies of wages and welfare, such as minimum wages, poor aid, and welfare programs. In looking at how we define and measure need, Vital Minimum raises profound questions about the authority of nature and the nature of inequality.
"Dana Simmons's marvelous and thoughtful new book takes on a question that many of us likely take for granted: 'What is a need; what is a want, a desire, a luxury? Vital Minimum offers an answer that emerges from and is embedded in the particular historical context of nineteenth century France, but has consequences that range well beyond modern French history. . . . Highly recommended!"
Carla Nappi | New Books in Science, Technology, and Society
"This unique book does a wonderful job of blending history with many other disciplines. Tracing a fluid arc from natural law to socialist political theory in post-WW II France, the author elaborates on issues of physical, social, and political need. She engages readers in the lively and passionate debate, which has raged in France since 1789, on the nature of inequality, giving them a fascinating look at the distinct French view on the matter and demonstrating that the current political debate on inequality has long and complicated origins. Highly recommended."
“[E]minently readable, likely because it recalls to the reader that the first meaning of history is ‘inquiry.’ Here the inquiry is motivated and driven by the ‘appeal of epochalist modes of social thought,’ which makes us see our contemporary times as different…Vital Minimum constructs new and interesting problems. In doing so, it asks more questions than it is able to answer. That, however, is no small achievement.”
American Historical Review
“How, one might wonder, did social questions about basic human subsistence and welfare become intertwined — even overwhelmed — by economic imperatives? Dana Simmons's Vital Minimum: Need, Science, and Politics in Modern France provides essential reading for anyone who has pondered this question. In this well-written and tightly-argued volume, Simmons examines how the concept of minimum needs emerged in a country often seen as the embodiment of the welfare state: France. Simmons's history brings together the agronomists, chemists, sociologists, anthropologists, and politicians who helped to create a ‘technopolitics of human needs’ during the nineteenth and twentieth centuries.”
Canadian Journal of History
"'Reason not the need,' admonishes King Lear. Yet for the past two hundred years scientists have done just that: they have deployed the tools of scientific inquiry to calculate the minimum needed to sustain life. What sort of life? As Dana Simmons shows in this remarkable book, a productive one—specifically, that of the male wage earner and his reproductive family unit. Chemists and agronomists have analyzed the feces and exhalations of laboring men and animals. Social scientists have assembled comparative scales of misery and family budgets. From Lavoisier's human machines and the Commune's ration cards to Vichy's eugenicist vital minimum and the postwar minimum wage, Simmons' lively and incisive history of 'need' transforms our understanding of the underpinnings of modern political economy, the welfare state, and modern science alike. Like Lear, Simmons warns us that to 'reason the need' is to value human life 'cheap as beasts.'"
Ken Alder, Northwestern University
"How did 'our daily bread' become the object of scientific experiment, philosophical debate, and mass politics? By untangling the threads of the 'vital minimum,' this elegant and eye-opening book provides nothing less than a hidden genealogy of the modern state and biopolitical citizenship. With a fascinating, discipline-scrambling cast of characters—including boxed-in-prisoners, early recyclers, starving families, panting chemists, and earnest economists—Simmons deftly analyzes the material technologies and the natural, moral, and political economies which merged and clashed in the race to set the lower limit on life. A must-read for historians of nineteenth and twentieth-century science, economics, and politics."
John Tresch, University of Pennsylvania
"An impressive study, drawing upon a range of neglected or unknown evidence, Vital Minimum is the first book to bring the important historical themes of consumption, nutrition science, and statistics together in a single volume—themes which are particularly timely given the economic troubles of recent years. Focusing on France from 1790 to the 1970s, Simmons offers a detailed and rigorous examination of the circumstances under which debates about need arose and were addressed. This is an extremely readable and thought-provoking book."
E. C. Spary, University of Cambridge
"Dana Simmons’s Vital Minimum: Need, Science, and Politics in Modern France is an extraordinarily ambitious and highly successful exploration of one of the key concepts lying at the interface of the biological and social sciences: “needs.” Noting the virtual omnipresence of the language of needs in modern-day social discourse, especially where social policy and economics intersect, and its highly moralized tone, Simmons seeks to trace a history of the regime of “needs” and how the term came to take on such power within modern French political culture (and, by extension, within the political cultures of most other European welfare states as well)."
Journal of Modern History
Table of Contents
Pigs on a balance
Bread and meat
Recycling and reproduction
3 Social Reform
4 Family, Race, Type
Welfare and comparative zoology
Family and race
Socialism and statistics
Useless mouths, get out!
Meat or bread
6 Vital Wages
Socialism, statistics, and the iron law
The fever of needs
7 Science of Man
The vital minimum wage
The science of man after 1945
8 Human Persons
Incompressible needs and the SMIG
An impossible standard
9 Need, Nature, and Society