Freedom and Despair
Notes from the South Hebron Hills
Freedom and Despair
Notes from the South Hebron Hills
David Shulman knows intimately what it takes to live your beliefs, to return, day after day, to the struggle, despite knowing you are often more likely to lose than win. Interweaving powerful stories and deep meditations, Freedom and Despair offers vivid firsthand reports from the occupied West Bank in Palestine as seen through the eyes of an experienced Israeli peace activist who has seen the Israeli occupation close up as it impacts on the lives of all Palestinian civilians.
Alongside a handful of beautifully written and often shocking tales from the field, Shulman meditates deeply on how to understand the evils around him, what it means to persevere as an activist decade after decade, and what it truly means to be free. The violent realities of the occupation are on full display. We get to know and understand the Palestinian shepherds and farmers and Israeli volunteers who face this situation head-on with nonviolent resistance. Shulman does not hold back on acknowledging the daily struggles that often leave him and his fellow activists full of despair. Inspired by these committed individuals who are not prepared to be silent or passive, Shulman suggests a model for ordinary people everywhere. Anyone prepared to take a risk and fight their oppressive political systems, he argues, can make a difference—if they strive to act with compassion and to keep hope alive.
This is the moving story of a man who continues to fight for good in the midst of despair. An indispensable book in our era of reactionary politics and refugee crises, political violence and ecological devastation, Freedom and Despair is a gripping memoir of struggle, activism, and hope for peace.
"Artful yet often passionately angry. . . . An earnest and valuable jeremiad insisting, reasonably, that ethical behavior is imperative when parsing the nearly impossible Israeli-Palestinian conundrum."
“[Shulman] sees injustice perpetuated by his neighbors, he sees his government defend the indefensible, and he knows that he must act, speak, and fight for better. His righteous sensibilities carry throughout Freedom and Despair, a persuasive, moving, and crucially needed account of resistance in these contentious times.”
"For fifteen years, David Shulman, a renowned scholar of South Asian languages and religion has been involved with Ta‘ayush, whose name is the Arabic word for coexistence. The group has been protesting in the South Hebron Hills, in Area C of the West Bank, where some 300,000 Palestinians, most of them farmers and shepherds, live, in about thirty villages. . . Freedom and Despair is an account of his experiences there and an attempt to understand the deep antipathy that drives the violence and destruction in the region."
New York Review of Books
"Shulman is a master storyteller. . . . His reflections are a thought-provoking and touching ode to activism and action—even when such activism is not, or cannot be, ultimately victorious. Freedom and Despair celebrates activism in the face of crushing odds."
"Poetic and filled with empathy. . . Compelling."
The Jerusalem Post
"Shulman eloquently and sensitively captures the beauty and the horror of the occupied West Bank. He is deeply attuned to the particularities and the paradoxes of the place."
"An important new book by Shulman, who has been trying to help Palestinians resist cruelty, abuse, and land theft by settlers and the military in the South Hebron hills for decades . . . [this is a] powerful moral interrogation of himself and others."
Hussein Ibish, Bloomberg
"No brief review of Freedom and Despair can adequately capture the richness of Shulman’s thinking and writing in the book. Page after page of this gripping account of Ta’ayush’s work sings of the hard-won rewards of a dogged persistence. . . . [t is the] barrier-busting expansiveness of heart and mind, that utterly disarming generosity of spirit as the very basis of non-violent action, that Shulman explores so beautifully in this book. Human rights practitioners should demand that those responsible for their organization’s next big planning exercise immerse themselves in a copy well before the first PowerPoint slide is crafted, and before that oft-times rather unthinkingly worshipped word ‘strategy’ is spoken."
Journal of Human Rights Practice
“With the skills of a novelist, Shulman effortlessly shifts from vivid thumbnail sketches of individuals to beautifully rendered depictions of the stark landscape to relentless self-interrogation. For all Americans in the new Trump era who are asking themselves, 'What can I do and how do I deal with my despair?'—Freedom and Despair is essential.”
Gabriel Levin, author of The Maltese Dreambook
“Shulman’s spell-binding narrative offers a captivating introduction to philosophical ideas extracted from the least likely of places—the remote and rugged hills of southern Hebron. Freedom and Despair is a meticulous soul-searching effort to articulate meanings that have captured the attention of philosophers throughout history: evil, distress, freedom, conscience, truth, and the mysterious state of being acquired by daring to say no to injustice.”
Sari Nusseibeh, professor of philosophy and former president, Al-Quds University, Jerusalem
“Beautifully written and emphatic . . . . essential reading for anyone who wants—or hopes, however darkly—to grasp the lay of this punished land.”—The Nation
“From 2002 to 2006, Shulman did some of the harder work of his country’s peace movement: clashing with police and settlers to deliver food and medical supplies to Palestinian villages. In his excellent record of these years, Dark Hope, Shulman vividly describes the small bands of Palestinians who live in caves in the Hebron Hills.”—Slate
Praise for Dark Hope
Table of Contents
Chapter One: On the Usefulness of Despair
Chapter Two: A Taste of South Hebron
Chapter Three: On Wickedness
Chapter Four: Freedom
Chapter Five: Thirst
Chapter Six: Truth, Trust, Conscience
Chapter Seven: Final Reflection: On Resistance
Chapter Eight: Iftar at Sarura