Darwin’s Evolving Identity

Adventure, Ambition, and the Sin of Speculation

Darwin’s Evolving Identity (High Resolution)

Cloth $50.00 ISBN: 9780226523118 Published March 2018

E-book $10.00 to $50.00 About E-books ISBN: 9780226523255 Published March 2018

Why—against his mentor’s exhortations to publish—did Charles Darwin take twenty years to reveal his theory of evolution by natural selection? In Darwin’s Evolving Identity, Alistair Sponsel argues that Darwin adopted this cautious approach to atone for his provocative theorizing as a young author spurred by that mentor, the geologist Charles Lyell. While we might expect him to have been tormented by guilt about his private study of evolution, Darwin was most distressed by harsh reactions to his published work on coral reefs, volcanoes, and earthquakes, judging himself guilty of an authorial “sin of speculation.” It was the battle to defend himself against charges of overzealous theorizing as a geologist, rather than the prospect of broader public outcry over evolution, which made Darwin such a cautious author of Origin of Species.

Drawing on his own ambitious research in Darwin’s manuscripts and at the Beagle’s remotest ports of call, Sponsel takes us from the ocean to the Origin and beyond. He provides a vivid new picture of Darwin’s career as a voyaging naturalist and metropolitan author, and in doing so makes a bold argument about how we should understand the history of scientific theories.

Table of Contents

Contents
Review Quotes
Awards

Contents

Preface

Introduction

Plans
Themes

Part I Theorizing on the Move

1 Darwin’s Opportunity

     Coral Reefs as Objects of Fascination and Terror
     Studying Reef Formation as an Objective of the Beagle Voyage
     Darwin’s Training in the Sciences
     Enthusiasm for the South Sea Islands

2 An Amphibious Being

     Darwin’s Approach to Scientific Work at the Beginning of the Voyage
     Hydrography Becomes a Resource for the Naturalist
     An Ambitious Plan for Studying Zoophytes

3 Studying Dry Land with a Maritime Perspective

Applying the Lessons of Hydrography to the Interpretation of Geology
Elevation and Subsidence

4 The Making of a Eureka Moment

     The Dangerous Reefs of the Low Archipelago
     The View from Tahiti
     Theorizing Like Humboldt in a Floating Library

5 The Surveyor-Naturalist

     Darwin’s Sea-Level Study of the South Keeling Reef
     Seeing Underwater: The Hydrographic Survey at South Keeling
     Darwin’s Hydrographic Initiative at Mauritius

Part II Training in Theory

6 Lyell Claims Darwin as a Student

     Homeward Bound as an Aspiring Geologist
     Lyell as an Author
     Master and Student
     The Primacy of Geology in Darwin’s Private, as Well as Public, Activities

7 Darwin’s Audacity, Lyell’s Choreography

     Going Public
     Putting the Coral Theory to Work
     Species
     An Astonished Response from the Geological Elite
     Darwin’s Emergence as a Practitioner of Lyellian Geological Speculation

8 Burned by Success

     Darwin’s New Persona
     The Obligations of a Student to His Master
     The Beginnings of Darwin’s Anxiety about Speculation

Part III A Different Approach to Authorship

9 The Life of a Tormented Geologist (and Enthusiastic Evolutionist)

     Darwin’s Turn toward Empiricism and the Ideal of Comprehensiveness
     The Pressure of Public Expectations
     Lyell’s Appropriation of the Coral Reef Theory
     Studying Species as a Diversion from the Task at Hand

10 A Finished Task: Darwin’s Treatise on Coral Reefs

     The Space between Lyell and Darwin
     A Mountain of Facts
     The Theory Emerges
     The Immediate Reaction to Coral Reefs
     A Theory in Use and in Memory

Part IV Writing the Origin with His “Fingers Burned”

11 Atoning for the Sin of Speculation

     Balancing Speculation with Facts
     Rejecting Lyell’s Suggestion to Publish a “Sketch”
     Lyell Choreographs Another Debut
     Publishing an “Abstract” After All: On the Origin of Species
     Dealing with Darwin’s “Recollections”

Conclusion

     Lyell, Darwin, and Authorship
     Studying Practices, Learning about Theories
     Acknowledgments
     Notes
     Bibliography
     Index

Review Quotes

The International Journal of Maritime History

"To say something new about Charles Darwin is no mean feat. . . . And yet, Alistair Sponsel has managed to say something new. In the process, he has also said something about how theories were made, careers were managed, books were written, and – perhaps most importantly for the readership of this journal – how shipboard natural history research was done. . . . Indeed, far from reproducing the teleological narrative that so often proceeds from the Galapagos to the Origin, Sponsel recasts the theory of evolution by means of natural selection as the result of a kind of wilful, anxious procrastination. It is an appealing notion to wilful procrastinators everywhere, who would do well to spend a few hours productively sounding the depths of Darwin's amphibious worlds before turning back to their own neglected manuscripts."

Quarterly Review of Biology

"One of the most interesting books on Darwin that I have read in a long time. . . . In a careful and most informative discussion, Sponsel focuses on Darwin’s geology, his all-encompassing scientific occupation in those early years after the Beagle voyage. . . . I learned so much from this volume."

Choice

"Sponsel takes a different slant on Darwin's scientific writing and life. Darwin's Evolving Identity deals with the publication of The Origin of Species, and how Darwin's decision to publish was affected by his contemporaries and colleagues. More could have been written here about Alfred Russel Wallace, another naturalist whose own findings on natural selection played a major role in pushing Darwin to finish writing Origin. Darwin was caught up in the work on coral reefs, which took time and energy away from his species efforts, which spanned decades. Darwin's coral reef studies helped establish him as a scientist and writer, earning him a place in the scientific hierarchy; but Darwin was wary of publishing Origin too soon, before thoroughly fleshing out his ideas. It was not until others seemed poised to beat him to the punch that Darwin was pushed to write and publish his findings. By the time Origin was published in 1859, it was largely accepted by colleagues; some (though not all) credited Darwin in their own work. This volume provides a detailed introduction to the scientific community in Darwin's time. Recommended."

Endeavour

"Sponsel resoundingly succeeds in his effort to reevaluate Darwin, making an important contribution to understanding Darwin as a scientific practitioner and as a writer. He also provides a useful exploration of the practice of scientific authorship and helps elucidate the use of evidence and speculation and the interplay between practice and theory in mid-nineteenth century British science. The book is clearly argued at every level, making plain along the way where and how it engages historiography and primary sources, in a way that is engaging and even elegant. Beyond its obvious interest to Darwin scholars and to the broader field of nineteenth century British science, this book will also appeal to a broader audience of students and enthusiasts who will find Sponsel's clear narrative approach highly accessible."

Janet Browne, Harvard University

“This lively, revisionist study transforms what we know about Charles Darwin’s early years as a practicing scientist. We see Darwin as a bold young geologist, stunning the geological community with his innovative theory of coral reef formation, and as a new author eager to manage his growing reputation by strategizing with his friend and mentor Charles Lyell. Sponsel puts geology back into the story of species. More than this, this insightful book explores the deep, and often challenging, relationships between knowledge, theory, and publication in the world of nineteenth century science.”

David Kaiser, Massachusetts Institute of Technology

“How difficult it is to recapture the young Charles Darwin, first navigating the shoals of scientific theorizing and authorship, long before he became the Darwin of legend. Yet in this engaging and original study, Alistair Sponsel accomplishes just that, delivering fresh insights into Darwin’s own evolution. Absolutely fascinating.”

Jim Secord, University of Cambridge

“Darwin’s Evolving Identity is an excellent—indeed outstanding—work of scholarship, which makes major interventions in the literature on Darwin and his theory, as well as setting these interventions in a broader context that will draw interest well beyond the specific world of Darwin studies.”

Gustave Lester | Nuncius

"Darwin’s Evolving Identity, intended for both specialists and the general reader, is a highly accessible and strictly chronological narrative. Along the way, Sponsel makes several significant contributions to science studies and astute, timely interventions into longstanding historiographical issues regarding Darwin’s life and work."

Greg Priest | HPLS

"Darwin’s Evolving Identity: Adventure, Ambition, and the Sin of Speculation is a subtle, scrupulous, and elegantly written book. While it makes important contributions to Darwin studies, it will also richly repay the attention of other scholars interested in the study of scientific practices."

ISIS: A Journal of the History of Science Society

"Sponsel’s book is a fine piece of scholarship in which he shows us just how deeply Darwin’s theorizing relied on the methods of scientific practice he employed."

History of Science Society: Pfizer Award
Short Listed

View Recent Awards page for more award winning books.

For more information, or to order this book, please visit https://press.uchicago.edu

Biological Sciences: Evolutionary Biology

Earth Sciences: History of Earth Sciences

History: History of Ideas

History of Science

Philosophy of Science

You may purchase this title at these fine bookstores. Outside the USA, see our international sales information.