Skip to main content

The Case Against the SAT

Every year, 1.5 million applicants to American colleges and universities take the Scholastic Aptitude Test. Over 1,500 colleges and universities either require or strongly recommend that applicants submit SAT scores. The College Entrance Examination Board and the Educational Testing Service claim that the SAT helps colleges select students, helps college-bound students select appropriate institutions, and furthers equality of opportunity. But does it really?

Drawing on three national surveys and on hundreds of studies conducted by colleges, James Crouse and Dale Trusheim refute the justifications the College Board and the ETS give for requiring high school students to take the SAT. They show that the test neither helps colleges and universities improve their admissions decisions nor helps applicants choose schools at which they will be successful. They outline the adverse effect the SAT has on students from nonwhite and low-income backgrounds. They also question the ability of the College Board and the ETS to monitor themselves adequately.

Crouse and Trusheim do not, however, recommend abolishing either college admissions testing or the College Board and the ETS. Rather, they propose dropping the SAT and relying on such already available measures as students’ high school coursework and grades, and they raise the possibility that new achievement tests that measure the mastery of high school courses could be developed to replace the SAT. The Case Against the SAT provides important new information for policymakers, college and university administrators, and researchers in testing and measurement. It forces a rethinking not only of what admissions testing accomplishes now but also of what it might and should accomplish in the future.

240 pages | 6.00 x 9.00 | © 1988

Education: Higher Education

Table of Contents

List of Tables
1. Can We Trust ETS and the College Board to Monitor Themselves?
2. Overselling the SAT since 1926
3. The SAT Does Not Help Colleges Make Better Selection Decisions
4. The SAT Does Not Help Applicants Select Colleges Where They Can Be Successful
5. The SAT Has an Adverse Impact on Black Applicants
6. The SAT Has an Adverse Impact on Low-Income Applicants
7. The Effects of the SAT Have Not Changed since 1960
8. What Is to Be Done?
Select Bibliography

Be the first to know

Get the latest updates on new releases, special offers, and media highlights when you subscribe to our email lists!

Sign up here for updates about the Press