What Did the Romans Know?
An Inquiry into Science and Worldmaking
9780226143217
9780226471143
9780226471150
What Did the Romans Know?
An Inquiry into Science and Worldmaking
What did the Romans know about their world? Quite a lot, as Daryn Lehoux makes clear in this fascinating and much-needed contribution to the history and philosophy of ancient science. Lehoux contends that even though many of the Romans’ views about the natural world have no place in modern science—the umbrella-footed monsters and dog-headed people that roamed the earth and the stars that foretold human destinies—their claims turn out not to be so radically different from our own.
Lehoux draws upon a wide range of sources from what is unquestionably the most prolific period of ancient science, from the first century BC to the second century AD. He begins with Cicero’s theologico-philosophical trilogy On the Nature of the Gods, On Divination, and On Fate, illustrating how Cicero’s engagement with nature is closely related to his concerns in politics, religion, and law. Lehoux then guides readers through highly technical works by Galen and Ptolemy, as well as the more philosophically oriented physics and cosmologies of Lucretius, Plutarch, and Seneca, all the while exploring the complex interrelationships between the objects of scientific inquiry and the norms, processes, and structures of that inquiry. This includes not only the tools and methods the Romans used to investigate nature, but also the Romans’ cultural, intellectual, political, and religious perspectives. Lehoux concludes by sketching a methodology that uses the historical material he has carefully explained to directly engage the philosophical questions of incommensurability, realism, and relativism.
By situating Roman arguments about the natural world in their larger philosophical, political, and rhetorical contexts, What Did the Romans Know? demonstrates that the Romans had sophisticated and novel approaches to nature, approaches that were empirically rigorous, philosophically rich, and epistemologically complex.
288 pages | 6 halftones, 4 line drawings, 2 tables | 6 x 9 | © 2012
Reviews
Table of Contents
Acknowledgments
1. The Web of Knowledge
A Roman World
A Roman World
Knowing Nature in the Roman Context
Overview
A Roman World
A Roman World
Knowing Nature in the Roman Context
Overview
2. Nature, Gods, and Governance
Divinity and Divination
Roman Virtues
Nature and the Legitimation of the Republic
A Ciceronian Contradiction?
Knowledge of Nature and Virtuous Action
Fabulae versus Learned Observation
Conclusion
3. Law in Nature, Nature in Law
Laws of Nature
Natural Laws
Human and Divine Governance
Is a “Law of Nature” Even Possible in Antiquity?
Divinity, Redux
Conclusion
4. Epistemology and Judicial Rhetoric
Theory-Ladenness and Observation
Observations as Models
Observational Selectivity
Examination of Witnesses
The Natural Authority of Morals
Declamation and Certainty
5. The Embeddedness of Seeing
Doubts about Vision
Mechanisms of Seeing in Antiquity
The Eyes as Organs
Not Every Black Box Is a Camera Obscura
Epistemologies of Seeing
The Centrality of Experience
6. The Trouble with Taxa
Knowledge Claims and Context-Dependence
Unproblematic Facticity
Problems with Experience
The Lab Section of the Chapter
The Question of Worlds
Epilogue
7. The Long Reach of Ontology
Four Kinds of Justification for Prediction
Predictability and Determinism
Physical Solutions to Determinism
The Cascading Effect
8. Dreams of a Final Theory
Explaining the Cosmos
Orbs, Souls, Laws
Numbers in Nature
Harmony and Empiricism
Conclusion
9. Of Miracles and Mistaken Theories
History as a Problem for Realism
Quantum Magnum PI?
Can We Avoid the Problems History Poses?
First Strategy: We Have Something They Didn’t
Second Strategy: The Curate’s Egg
Other Ways Out
10. Worlds Given, Worlds Made
What’s in a World?
Kuhn’s World
What Good Is Relativism?
Coherence
Truth and Meaning
Realism, Coherence, and History
11. Conclusion
Appendix: Lemma to the Mirror Problem
Reference List
Index
Be the first to know
Get the latest updates on new releases, special offers, and media highlights when you subscribe to our email lists!